Borderlands 4 Reviews: A Redemption Arc or a Safe
Borderlands 4 review: Gearbox’s looter-shooter fixes Borderlands 3’s flaws with open-world gameplay, though its safe villain and story may feel dull.
I’ve been a Borderlands fan since the original, and like many of you, I was left feeling a bit… underwhelmed by Borderlands 3. The humor felt forced, the villains were annoying, and the story just didn’t land. So when Borderlands 4 was announced, I was cautiously optimistic. Now that we’re in 2026 and the dust has settled, the reviews are in, and it looks like Gearbox might have actually pulled it off. But is it the massive improvement everyone hoped for, or did they play it too safe? Let’s dive in.
The Consensus: A Big Step Up from Borderlands 3
If you’ve been living under a rock, here’s the scoop: Borderlands 4 is being praised as a course correction for the series. Our own review at Screen Rant boldly called it “the best game in the series so far.” IGN said it’s “the massive kick in the pants [the series] needed” after “fizzling somewhat with Borderlands 3.” That’s high praise, right? Even other outlets agree it’s a step in the right direction, even if it’s not perfect.
But here’s where it gets interesting. GameSpot noted that Borderlands 4 fixing its predecessor’s issues also works “to its detriment.” They said, “Borderlands 4 is cranked so far in the other direction that the resulting game feels like a strange imitation of the series.” Ouch. So, is it possible to overcorrect? Maybe. But from what I’ve seen, the core looter-shooter gameplay is still intact and satisfying, so I’m willing to forgive a little identity crisis.
The Villain Problem: Timekeeper vs. Handsome Jack
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room: the antagonist. Borderlands 3 gave us the Twins, who were widely considered annoying and cringey. Borderlands 4 introduces The Timekeeper. According to GamesRadar, “The Timekeeper is a very safe antagonist – which is an improvement upon Borderlands 3’s actively abrasive Twins, but still rather dull.” So, not a home run, but at least he’s not actively hated.
GameSpot added that “Borderlands 4 seems to do everything in its power to make sure that its characters cannot be hated.” Is that a good thing? Well, after the Twins, maybe a safe, inoffensive villain is exactly what the series needed. It’s like they said, “Let’s not make everyone mad this time.” And honestly, I’ll take dull over grating any day.
Open World and Gameplay: The Real Star
The big advancement here is the open-world design. Reviews are celebrating it as a high point. I’ve always loved the semi-open areas of previous games, but a full open world? That sounds like a dream. The gameplay is making significant strides, and many reviewers note that the series’ typically irreverent humor comes out in the side content, while the main story is a bit more dramatic. That balance might be the key to pleasing both old-school fans and newcomers.
Is It the Best in the Series?
Screen Rant’s assertion that it’s the best game in the series is particularly interesting, since Borderlands 2 has reigned supreme since 2012. Handsome Jack is a tough act to follow. The Timekeeper doesn’t appear to be Handsome Jack-level compelling, but the gameplay iteration seems to have picked up the slack. So, can a game with a “safe” story and a “dull” villain still be the best? If the gameplay is that good, absolutely.
Let’s break down the pros and cons as I see them based on the reviews:
Pros 
Cons 
Open-world design is a delight
Story is safe and unremarkable
Gameplay improvements are significant
Villain is dull compared to Handsome Jack
Humor is back in side content
Main story takes itself more seriously (could be good or bad)
Fixes many of Borderlands 3’s issues
Overcorrection makes it feel like an imitation at times
My Take: Cautiously Optimistic
As a longtime fan, I’m excited. It sounds like Borderlands 4 is a hit, taking significant strides and making a concerted effort to fix its predecessor’s issues. Will it dethrone Borderlands 2 in my heart? Only time will tell. But for now, I’m just happy that Gearbox seems to be listening to the fans. What do you think? Are you ready to dive back into Pandora (or wherever this one takes place)? Let me know in the comments!
So there you have it. Borderlands 4 might not be perfect, but it’s a massive step in the right direction. And after